Aaron Boyajian, Managing Partner of Goetz Fitzpatrick LLP, Represents Barry McTiernan & Moore in Headquarters Relocation to One Battery Park Plaza

Aaron BoyajianBlog Post, Insight, Latest news

Contact:
Aaron Boyajian
212-695-7460
[email protected]

Aaron Boyajian, Managing Partner of Goetz Fitzpatrick LLP, Represents Barry McTiernan & Moore in Headquarters Relocation to One Battery Park Plaza

In a strategic move, law firm Barry McTiernan & Moore is set to relocate its headquarters to One Battery Park Plaza, as announced by landlord Rudin. The legal defense firm, expertly represented by Aaron Boyajian, Managing Partner of Goetz Fitzpatrick LLP, has inked a significant 16-year lease for 18,464 square feet on the top floor of the iconic 35-story building. The New York Post initially reported on this milestone. 

With an asking rent of $70 per square foot, this relocation marks a pivotal moment for Barry McTiernan & Moore, which will be moving from its current space of approximately 18,000 square feet at 101 Greenwich Street. 

Founded in 1930, Barry McTiernan & Moore has built a strong reputation for providing expert counsel to insurance companies grappling with general liability claims. The firm has also been instrumental in defending companies across the New York metro area against environmental class actions, including those involving asbestos, talcum powder, benzene, silica, lead poisoning, and chemical exposures. 

Mark Weiss of Cushman & Wakefield (CWK), who facilitated the deal alongside Jonathan Schindler, praised Barry McTiernan & Moore as a “highly respected firm, a leader in the field.” Weiss further noted the exceptional accommodation provided by Rudin, underscoring their commitment to meeting the needs of their tenants. 

This relocation to One Battery Park Plaza signifies not only the expansion and evolution of Barry McTiernan & Moore but also underscores the attractiveness of the building as a prime destination for prominent companies making strategic moves in the heart of New York City. 

Read More: Law Firm Barry McTiernan & Moore Moving HQ to 18K SF at One Battery Park Plaza – Commercial Observer 


Goetz Fitzpatrick has been practicing law throughout the New York Metropolitan area and The Hamptons, since 1967. The firm has deep expertise in Construction and Real Estate, as well as Corporate, Bankruptcy, Trust & Estates and Labor & Employment. The firm’s office is located at One Penn Plaza, Suite 3100, New York, NY 10119, Telephone 212 695 8100.


Navigating New Property Disclosure Requirements in New York: How Goetz Fitzpatrick LLP Can Assist You

Alison Arden BesunderBlog Post, Insight, Latest news

Contact:
Alison Arden Besunder
212-710-4999
[email protected]

John Simoni
212-695-7765
[email protected]

Navigating New Property Disclosure Requirements in New York: How Goetz Fitzpatrick LLP Can Assist You

For homeowners in New York State, staying up-to-date with recent changes to property disclosure laws is crucial. On September 23, 2023, significant amendments were made to the Property Condition Disclosure Act (PCDA) and the Property Condition Disclosure Statement (PCDS), set to take effect on March 20, 2024. These changes will impact property transactions across the state, and Goetz Fitzpatrick LLP is here to help you navigate the process.

A notable update is the issuance of a new Property Condition Disclosure Statement (PCDS) form by the Department of State, replacing the previous version. This updated form incorporates the latest legal requirements and standards, and it will be mandatory for property transactions moving forward. You can access the new PCDS form on the Department’s website here: https://dos.ny.gov/system/files/documents/2024/03/dos-1614-f-property-condition-disclosure-statement_01.2024.pdf

In addition to changes to the PCDS form, Governor Kathy Hochul signed legislation requiring homeowners to disclose flood risks when selling their properties. This legislation amends Article 14 of the Real Property Law, focusing on disclosing flood risks associated with the property. Sellers are now obligated to provide information about the property’s flood history and its flood insurance claim history to potential buyers. This additional disclosure aims to provide buyers with crucial information to make informed decisions about properties located in flood-prone areas.

Of particular importance is the amendment to RPL Section 465, eliminating the option for sellers to offer a $500 credit to buyers in lieu of completing and executing the Property Condition Disclosure. With this amendment, all sellers will now be required to sign and provide the disclosure to buyers.

These changes have significant implications for both buyers and sellers in New York’s real estate market. Buyers can expect more comprehensive information about properties they are considering, particularly regarding flood risks. Sellers must ensure they understand and comply with the updated disclosure requirements to avoid any potential legal consequences.

As the March 20, 2024 effective date approaches, Goetz Fitzpatrick LLP is ready to assist homeowners and real estate agents involved in property transactions. Our team can provide guidance on navigating the new disclosure requirements, ensuring compliance, and facilitating smooth transactions. With our expertise, you can navigate these changes with confidence, knowing that you have a trusted partner by your side.


Goetz Fitzpatrick has been practicing law throughout the New York Metropolitan area and The Hamptons, since 1967. The firm has deep expertise in Construction and Real Estate, as well as Corporate, Bankruptcy, Trust & Estates and Labor & Employment. The firm’s office is located at One Penn Plaza, Suite 3100, New York, NY 10119, Telephone 212 695 8100.


Goetz Fitzpatrick Secures Victory for NY Real Estate Broker in Multi-Million-Dollar AAA Arbitration Case Over South Carolina Mall Purchase Allegations

Howard RubinBlog Post, Insight, Latest news

Contact:
Howard Rubin
212-695-7753
[email protected]

Scott Simon
212-465-1596
[email protected]

Mark Lafayette
212-710-4996
[email protected]

Goetz Fitzpatrick Secures Victory for NY Real Estate Broker in Multi-Million-Dollar AAA Arbitration Case Over South Carolina Mall Purchase Allegations

Goetz Fitzpatrick successfully defended a leading NY Real Estate Broker in a case brought by a developer in which it was claimed that the broker had violated fiduciary duties and made misrepresentations regarding a purchase of a mall in South Carolina.  After multiple days of arbitration, the arbitrator found in favor of the broker. We were successful in representing the respondent in the major muti-million-dollar AAA Arbitration which resulted in all claims being dismissed. Howard Rubin led the Goetz Fitzpatrick team assisted by Scott Simon, Mark Lafayette and Gina Leon.


Goetz Fitzpatrick has been practicing law throughout the New York Metropolitan area and The Hamptons, since 1967. The firm has deep expertise in Construction and Real Estate, as well as Corporate, Bankruptcy, Trust & Estates and Labor & Employment. The firm’s office is located at One Penn Plaza, Suite 3100, New York, NY 10119, Telephone 212 695 8100.


2024 Construction Seminar: The Framework for Success

Wednesday, March 27, 2024, 9:00 AM - 10:00 AM EST
HUB International Northeast
5 Bryant Park - 4th Floor
New York, NY 10018

2024 Construction Seminar: The Framework for Success

Join the team of experts from HUB International and Goetz Fitzpatrick LLP for an informative, can’t-miss seminar for the Construction Industry, where we’ll discuss:

  • Chapter 33 of NYC Building Code
  • Local Law 11
  • Neighbor Access Agreements and RPAPL 881
  • Important Insurance and Risk Considerations
  • And Much More!
Don't miss this opportunity to gain valuable insights from industry experts. 2024 Construction Seminar: The Framework for Success Flyer

Learn more >
Participants

Joshua G. Oberman
Andrea Lawrence


Unraveling the Corporate Transparency Act

Alison Arden BesunderBlog Post, Insight, Latest news

Contact:
Alison Arden Besunder
212-695-8100, ext. 289
[email protected]

Aaron Boyajian
212-695-8100, ext. 258
[email protected]

The Corporate Transparency Act (CTA) (www.fincen.gov/boi) is now in effect, bringing forth pivotal changes in reporting obligations for diverse entities. At Goetz Fitzpatrick LLP, we recognize the intricate landscape this legislation introduces and are committed to guiding our clients through its nuances. The CTA mandates beneficial ownership reporting, aiming to bolster transparency and combat financial misconduct. If your entity falls within the scope of this regulation or requires assistance with the Beneficial Ownership Information (BOI) report, our adept team stands ready to assist. Reach out to us for support and guidance on CTA compliance.

What Is the Corporate Transparency Act: Your Comprehensive Compliance Guide

The Corporate Transparency Act (CTA), implemented on January 1, 2021, under the National Defense Authorization Act, substantially reforms anti-money laundering laws. Its primary aim is to curb money laundering, terrorist financing, corruption, and tax fraud by mandating beneficial ownership reporting for various entities operating in the United States.

Key Points:

Effective Dates: The reporting obligations came into force on January 1, 2024. Entities formed before this date have until January 1, 2025, to comply.

Filing Requirements: Filing deadlines differ based on entity formation dates, with a grace period provided for entities established in 2024.

Reporting Companies: Various domestic and foreign entities, known as reporting companies, are mandated to submit beneficial ownership information to FinCEN.

Exemptions: Several categories, such as banks, tax-exempt entities, and certain partnerships, are exempt from reporting. A “large operating company” is also excluded based on specific criteria.

Tax-Exempt Entities: Tax-exempt entities must monitor their status; if they lose their exemption, they need to report within 180 days.

Information Required: Details about the company, beneficial owners, and company applicants are needed, including identification documents, such as a registration certificate.

Submission Method: Reports must be submitted electronically through FinCEN’s Beneficial Ownership Secure System (BOSS).

Access and Confidentiality: The disclosed information is accessible to authorized recipients for defined purposes, with security and confidentiality protocols.

Updates and Corrections: Reporting companies must promptly update or correct any inaccuracies or changes within specific time frames.

Penalties: Non-compliance, including false reporting, can result in civil or criminal penalties.

FinCEN Identifier: While not mandatory, a unique FinCEN identifier may be obtained and utilized to streamline reporting processes.

Conclusion:

The CTA’s implementation imposes stringent reporting requirements on various entities, aiming to enhance transparency and combat financial crimes. Understanding these obligations and adhering to reporting timelines and accuracy is crucial to avoid penalties and ensure compliance with the law. In all instances, businesses and entities should familiarize themselves with the law’s provisions and seek legal counsel to ensure adherence to regulatory requirements.

For entities which Goetz Fitzpatrick forms for its clients after January 1, 2024, we will work to guide them through the CTA compliance process.  For entities which were formed prior to January 1, 2024, you may be contacted by our office to assist in the CTA compliance process, however, if not, we strongly recommend that you contact us to assist you in the CTA compliance process so that you avoid potential non-compliance and the rigorous penalties which accompany non-compliance.


Goetz Fitzpatrick has been practicing law throughout the New York Metropolitan area and The Hamptons, since 1967. The firm has deep expertise in Construction and Real Estate, as well as Corporate, Bankruptcy, Trust & Estates and Labor & Employment. The firm’s office is located at One Penn Plaza, Suite 3100, New York, NY 10119, Telephone 212 695 8100.


Major Impact on NYS Private Construction: 5% Maximum Retainage on Private Construction Contracts

Gerard StrainBlog Post, Insight, Latest news

Major Impact On All Nys Private Construction Contracts As Nys Governor Hochul Signs Law To Mandate 5% Maximum Retainage On All Private Construction Contracts And Payment Of Retainage Can Now Be Sought Upon Substantial Completion

 

On November 17, 2023, NYS Governor Kathy Hochul signed into law significant modifications to General Business Law §§756-A and 756-C which will have a great impact on construction agreements for private projects.  Specifically, GBL §756-A was amended to now provide that contractors and subcontractors may submit a final invoice for work performed and the release of retainage upon substantial completion of the project.   Also, GBL §756-C was amended to provide that five percent (5%) of the contract sum is the maximum allowable retainage that can be withheld from the contractor or subcontractor (as the case may be), during the project.

Retainage Must Now Be Released Upon “Substantial Completion”

Prior to the effective date of the new law, which is November 17, 2023, GBL §756-A entitled a contractor or subcontractor to submit a final invoice for payment “upon the performance of all the contractor’s obligation under the contract…”  This language was generally taken to mean final completion – that is, after all punch list work is complete and all work has been approved by owner, architect, or both.  Among the purposes of GBL-756-A was so the owner could have some assurance that the contractor would return to the project to complete punch list work, and to secure the owner (to some degree) for defects, costs, and possible back charges that it might have against the contractor at the end of the project.  This owner-driven protection, however, often frustrated many contractors as owners sometimes withheld retainage for an unreasonable amount of time and leveraged it to extract additional work from the contractor without additional payment.

Now, the newly passed modification to GBL §756-A.2 drastically changes the above-quoted statutory language and provides that:

A contractor shall be entitled to submit a final invoice for payment in full upon reaching substantial completion, as such term is defined in the contract or as it is contemplated by the terms of the contract. 

(Emphasis added).

Most people who work in construction and development, including construction law practitioners, commonly recognize “substantial completion” to mean when the property can be used for its intended purpose and that often correlates to when the temporary certificate of occupancy is issued by the governmental agency with authority over such matters.

The language in the newly passed legislation must be taken into consideration during the negotiation and drafting of the construction contract so there is no misunderstanding of the term “substantial completion” and when the contractor is entitled to receive its retainage.

Retainage is Now Limited to 5%

GBL 756-C used to provide permit the parties to agree on a “reasonable amount” of retainage, and what was “reasonable” was often negotiated by the parties but usually landed at 10%.  Not anymore!

As of November 17, 2023, GBL §756-C mandates that “an owner may retain no more than five percent per annum of the contract sum as retainage.”

While the 5% difference between the usual (now unlawful) 10% and the newly legislated 5% maximum retainage may not appear much, the delta becomes more obvious the larger the project.

For owners, it is a loss of a certain level of security and leverage; for contractors, it means more of the contract sum and payment sooner rather than later, which is the stated purpose of the new legislation.


Goetz Fitzpatrick has been practicing law throughout the New York Metropolitan area and The Hamptons, since 1967. The firm has deep expertise in Construction and Real Estate, as well as Corporate, Bankruptcy, Trust & Estates and Labor & Employment. The firm’s office is located at One Penn Plaza, Suite 3100, New York, NY 10119, Telephone 212 695 8100.


Goetz Fitzpatrick Wins Ruling that New York City’s Implementation of Joint Bidding for Public Infrastructure Contracts is Unlawful

Donald J. CarboneInsight, Latest news

Goetz Fitzpatrick attorneys Donald J. Carbone and Scott D. Simon recently obtained a landmark ruling that New York City’s imposition of “JB 4.0” – a joint bidding scheme that gave private utility companies a windfall at the expense of the City and its taxpayers – violates the law.

Like all municipalities, the City is required by statute to procure contracts for a publicly funded project by soliciting bids and awarding the work to the lowest responsible bidder. Another law compels private utilities like Con Edison to protect its wires and pipes at the utilities’ own cost when the City is repairing its streets and sidewalks. Historically, contractors submitted two bids on such projects – one to perform the City’s public work, and a second for the related work to protect the private utilities’ property.

However, under JB 4.0, the City directed contractors to submit a joint bid for the projects that mandated a fixed price for the private utility work. The contractors, all City taxpayers, contended that the City-mandated price for the portion of the bid covering the private utility work was priced massively below what the work cost to perform. Goetz Fitzpatrick successfully argued on behalf of its clients – JLJ IV Enterprises, Inc.; ADC Construction, LLC; DiFazio Industries LLC; Perfetto Contracting Co., Inc.; and J. Pizzirusso Landscaping Corp. – that by requiring contractors to bid a massively undervalued price to perform the private utility work, the contractors had no choice but to bid a higher price to perform the City’s public work than they would if JB 4.0 were not in place. This is because the portion of the bid relating to the City’s public work was the only portion of the project for which the bidders had any discretion as to their submitted price.

Goetz Fitzpatrick LLP argued that a resulting higher price for the City’s public work meant that the City was not obtaining the lowest responsible bid on these projects and was subsidizing the private utilities at the expense of New York City taxpayers. The firm’s efforts resulted in a determination that JB 4.0 does not protect the public fisc or safeguard the public interest, in violation of longstanding law. Accordingly, the Court struck down the City’s JB 4.0 bidding scheme.


Goetz Fitzpatrick has been practicing law throughout the New York Metropolitan area and the Hamptons, since 1967. The firm has deep expertise in Construction and Real Estate, as well as Corporate, Bankruptcy, Trust & Estates and Labor & Employment. The firm’s office is located at One Penn Plaza, Suite 3100, New York, NY 10119, Telephone 212 695 8100.


Congratulations to Our 2022 Super Lawyers!

 |  AwardLatest news
Great news – seven members of the Goetz Fitzpatrick team have been selected for recognition this year by SuperLawyers®! We couldn't be prouder of all of you.
Congratulations to Alison Arden BesunderDonald J. CarboneGary M. KushnerJoshua G. ObermanJohn B. Simoni, and Gerard S. Strain for being included in the 2022 New York Metro Super Lawyers list!
Congratulations also to Andrew P. Herrera for making the 2022 New York Metro Rising Stars list!
It's always wonderful to know that others see what we see in our hard-working, top-tier team.
Thank you so much for all you do for us and our clients every day – here's to another year of exceptional service and results!

Congratulations to Our 2022 Super Lawyers!

 
Senior Partner
Senior Partner
Senior Partner
Senior Partner
Partner
Senior Counsel

Congratulations to Our 2022 Rising Stars!

 
Senior Counsel

PR: Doodle For Hunger, November 9th

 |  AnnouncementLatest news
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE October 19, 2022 Contact: Howard M. Rubin, 212-695-8100, ext. 334, [email protected] November 9th is the Doodle for Hunger XXIII Celebrity Art Auction, which this year includes a tribute to NHL New York Rangers legend Rod Gilbert. Up for auction this year is a variety of original signed drawings by Marc Brown, Narciso Rodriguez, Carol Burnett, Andy Cohen, Cardinal Timothy Dolan, and Jeanine Pirro. Proceeds from this event benefit St. Francis Food Pantries and Shelters, where our own Howard Rubin serves as committee chair. This organization provides a range of social services and community programs that help to feed, clothe, and counsel poor families – every bit of support makes a difference! The auction takes place at Pier 60 on Wednesday, November 9, with the reception and silent auction beginning at 6 PM and the live auction starting at 7. Howard Rubin, a Senior Partner at Goetz Fitzpatrick LLP, serves as Committee Chair for St. Francis Food Pantries & Shelters. Learn more: St. Francis Food Pantries & Shelters - Doodle for Hunger 2022 (stfrancispantries.org)

Goetz Fitzpatrick Scores a Legal Victory in an 881 Proceeding

 |  AnnouncementLatest news
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
August 30, 2022
Contact: Joshua G. Oberman, 212.695.8100 x317, [email protected]

New York, NY — Attorneys Joshua G. Oberman, Gerard S. Strain, and Benjamin Blum from Goetz Fitzpatrick, had a major victory in an 881 proceeding this month.

Goetz Fitzpatrick represented HAP, a developer in connection with its project on Franklin Street in Tribeca. The owner of the adjacent property, alleged that HAP caused damage to its building during the course of construction.

After the alleged damage, HAP needed access to the neighbor’s building to perform additional construction on its project. Pursuant to the law, HAP sought an access agreement to enter onto its neighbor’s property. The neighbor denied HAP access. It alleged that HAP sought to install underground bracing that was a “permanent intrusion”. Furthermore, it argued that HAP couldn’t enter the property until it paid the neighbor monetary damages.

Goetz Fitzpatrick immediately filed an 881 on HAP’s behalf. The Court rejected both of the neighbor’s arguments, going so far as to call them “dubious”. The Court granted HAP access for 24 months, ordering it only to pay the neighbor’s legal fees, and a small access fee (which Goetz Fitzpatrick offered to pay in its motion papers). The neighbor had originally demanded an exorbitant sum to grant access to HAP.
Goetz Fitzpatrick has been practicing law throughout the New York Metropolitan area and the Hamptons, since 1967. The firm has deep expertise in Construction and Real Estate, as well as Corporate, Bankruptcy, Trust & Estates and Labor & Employment. The firm's office is located at One Penn Plaza, Suite 3100, New York, NY 10119, Telephone 212 695 8100.