The Implications of a Proposed New York State Heirs Tax

Christopher CanfieldBlog Post

New York State faces a budget deficit of $15 billion over the next two fiscal years. In what is proclaimed to be an effort to avoid cutting funding for education and social services programs, New York State legislators in both chambers have proposed an “Heirs Tax,” which they claim will raise $8 billion annually. This is a companion bill to proposed legislation that would tax New York’s top earners, a move Governor Cuomo has opposed, arguing it will force New York’s wealthiest residents to relocate, thereby depriving New York of base tax revenue on which the state depends.

New York’s current estate tax law provides that inheritances up to $5.93 million are exempt from state estate taxes. There is a “cliff tax” that subjects the entirety of the Estate to state estate taxes if the taxable estate exceeds 105% of the exemption. The proposed Heirs Tax bill seeks to drastically reduce that threshold and also add a gift tax.  New York currently does not have a gift tax, although it does “claw back” gifts made within three years of a decedent’s estate for the purpose of calculating the gross estate. Proposals in the Heirs Tax bill include:

  • imposing a NYS tax beginning at 5% on estates over $250,000
    • retirement and pensions would be exempt
    • a $2 million primary residence exclusion would be allowed for estates under $5 Million
  • levying a marginal tax of 50% on assets over $10 Million
  • instituting a gift tax
    • 5% on gifts from $50,000 to $100,000
    • 50% on gifts exceeding $2 Million

It should be noted that the NYS Senate and Assembly have recently released separate bills calling for an increase to the estate tax rates but with no reference to the more substantial changes referred to above. All of these changes face uncertain prospects for passage but warrant watching.

The current New York State estate tax exemption remains in place until January 1, 2022, however, any new legislation could be retroactive. In addition, the federal estate tax exemption is at an historic high ($11.7 million per person; $23.4 million per couple with portability). This summary is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended to be relied on as legal advice, which depends on each individual situation. If one of your objectives is preserving more of your assets for future generations and avoiding it being eroded by estate taxes, and you would like to discuss strategies that will protect your assets now and in the future, contact us at 212.695.8100 ext. 289.


Selecting Your Beneficiaries

Andrew P. HerreraBlog Post

Selecting your beneficiaries is one of the most important parts of your estate plan. A beneficiary of your estate is the recipient of all or a portion of your estate. Beneficiaries of your estate can include family, friends, charities, or trusts.

What to consider when selecting a beneficiary
Often times, clients struggle with a few key questions when considering who to select as the beneficiaries of their estates, such as:

  • Who should I list as a beneficiary/beneficiaries?
  • How much should I leave each beneficiary?
  • Should the bequest be stated in the will and paid outright or held in trust for my beneficiaries?

Other things to consider in terms of the beneficiaries are the laws of the state which control the distributions, the estate tax implications, if any, and the needs of a beneficiary.

Have a backup plan

You should also think of who you want as an alternate beneficiary. An alternate beneficiary should be selected in the event the primary beneficiary predeceases you. If the primary beneficiary predeceased you and you did not name an alternate beneficiary, then the bequest lapses and becomes invalid, and will either pass to the residuary beneficiaries or by intestacy as deemed by the court.

Assets passing by intestacy means that the inheritance will pass pursuant to the law. The applicable statute in New York is Estates, Powers & Trusts Law (EPTL) Section 4-1.1. This section provides that the inheritance will pass to the closest family member, e.g., spouse, children, parents.

Laws dictating beneficiaries

Individuals that require special consideration are surviving spouses and minors. In New York, a surviving spouse is protected by the law and must receive a portion of an estate. The applicable statute in New York is EPTL Section 5-1.1-A. This section provides that the surviving spouse has a personal right of election which provides that the surviving spouse shall take the greater of:

  • Fifty Thousand Dollars ($50,000.00)
  • One-third (1/3) of the net estate.

The same does not apply to children. There is no law requiring that an individual include their children as a beneficiary of their estate. When minor children are named as beneficiaries, they can receive their share outright or in trust. New York does not allow a minor to own property outright and requires the appointment of a Guardian of the Property to manage the property until the minor reaches the age of 18. Our office encourages clients to have all amounts paid to minors to be held in-trust until a specific age which avoids the additional time and expense of needing a Guardian of the Property.

Please feel free to contact the attorneys of the Trusts & Estates Group at Goetz Fitzpatrick LLP at 212.695.8100 ext. 289 to discuss any questions you may have regarding creating or updating your estate plan.


What to Expect When Meeting with an Estate Planning Attorney

Alison Arden BesunderBlog Post

Are you unsure of what to expect during the estate planning process? Read this Q&A, prompted by a response we got from “The Perfect New Year’s Resolution: Developing your Estate Plan.”

Q: I am making it my New Year’s resolution to meet with an estate planning attorney but the reason I’ve been putting it off in the first place is that I have no idea what I need to prepare in advance to make the meeting efficient and successful. What kinds of documents do I need to bring with me? What types of questions will the attorney ask?

A: If you have made the decision to meet with an estate planner, congratulations. You will thank yourself in the future. Now, before your meeting, there are some questions you should be prepared to answer. These are some of the major points you will want to consider regarding your estate.

Guardians and Alternate Guardians of Minor Children Who do you want to serve as guardian should something happen to you? Who do you want to appoint as successor guardian if the primary guardian is unable, unwilling, or unavailable to serve? Do you want the guardian’s spouse or another individual to serve as co-guardian? Do you want a different guardian to be appointed for different children? Should a bond be required? Where do you want your minor children to live? Do you want your children to live in their guardian’s home, or would you like your guardian and their family to move into your home? In either case, will there be a need for capital to make improvements to accommodate or house the expanded family unit?

Trustee(s) and Successor Trustee(s) for Minors’ Trust Minors’ Trustees are effectively guardians of the property of your minor children. They oversee the money left to your children if they are still minors (usually when both spouses predecease). The Trustee does not need to be the same person as the guardian, and there are certain merits to keeping them separate, i.e., ensuring checks and balances on the money and distributions, and ensuring that both sides of a family are in contact after the parents are deceased. The guardian is usually someone who you feel can impart the most important values to your children, while the Trustee is someone who can handle money, will be responsible, and have a long-term view of preserving principal while balanced against providing for the minor children.

Age at Which Minor Children Receive Money If both spouses pass away, you need to specify at what age your children will receive distributions of remaining principal. While the Trustee usually has the discretion to distribute both income and principal for the health, education, maintenance, and support for the minors (a fairly broad standard), you need to state at which age the minor children will receive what is left. One common setup is to allow for 100% of the remainder (or their share) at the age of 21, 25, 30, or 35. Another is to allow for one third each at age 25, 30, and 35. Another is to allow for half at age of 25 and the other half at 30 if the child graduates from an (accredited) college or graduate school, otherwise at 30 and 35.

Executors Spouses are usually named executors for the other’s will, as well as successors. An exception can be in second marriages where there are children of the first marriage and the Testator wants to ensure that the assets pass to the children of the first marriage after the death of the second spouse. Things to consider: Do you want your executor to be compensated? Do you want to impose a limitation on the amount of compensation they should receive? Keep in mind that being an Executor (or Trustee) can entail a lot of work – it is essentially managing the aspects of your personal life that you manage now, such as balancing bank accounts and maintaining oversight over assets and satisfying liabilities. Should your Executor be required to post a bond? (i.e., insurance if the Executor loses or absconds with money).

Wills and Credit Shelter Trusts Each spouse can establish a Credit Shelter Trust in his or her will up to the maximum amount that can be exempt from federal estate taxes; currently $5.34 million for 2014 and adjusted annually for inflation. A Credit Shelter Trust can also help save on state estate taxes. This Trust is typically funded at death with the surviving spouse being named the co-Trustee. Each spouse must choose a co-Trustee that the other will feel comfortable serving with. As with any fiduciary, you should choose someone who is responsible and a “prudent” investor, but who will also make distributions to provide for the spouse. You want to choose a “friendly” Trustee that will cooperate, so that if your spouse needs access to principal for a reasonable purpose, the Trustee will not deny that distribution.

Insurance Trust The insurance trust, or irrevocable life insurance trust (ILIT), is often used to set aside cash proceeds that can be used to pay estate taxes, as the life insurance policy should be exempt from the taxable estate of the decedent. Once placed in the trust, the insured person no longer owns the policy, and it will be managed by the Trustee on behalf of the policy beneficiaries when the insured person dies. Again, as with choosing any fiduciary for a living or testamentary trust, you should pick a Trustee that is prudent but not unreasonable, and that the surviving spouse can work with after you die.

Advance Directive (also called Power of Attorney, Health Care Proxy) These are documents that are effective during your lifetime. Spouses usually name each other to make decisions for them, with successor agents to act in the event that the spouse is unable. While you can name one or more co-agents on the Power of Attorney, only one person can act at a time under a Health Care Proxy in New York. Successor agents are critical and should be identified, together with their appropriate contact information.

Living Will A living will is a directive authorizing your agent to withhold certain life-sustaining measures (such as artificial respiration, CPR, resuscitation) in the event that you are suffering from a condition from which you will not recover. Absence of a Living Will does not mean that the agent cannot make those decisions, however, the Living Will gives the health care agent the comfort, assurance, and authority to make those decisions in the event of a dispute with another family member or the hospital or health care professionals.

Special Bequests You should identify any specific items such as art, valuable books, collections, jewelry, heirlooms, or outright monetary bequests that you want to be given to certain individuals, and specify them in your will. New York does not recognize personal property memoranda that are outside the will. It is at the discretion of the Executor whether to honor them, but are non-binding.

Taker of Last Resort and Common Disaster Clause If both spouses and children pass away, where will the money go? Typically it goes to parents, siblings, nieces, and nephews. However, consider the situation of those people – leaving money to your parents could disrupt their own long-term planning needs and any Medicaid or other government benefits they might be receiving.


The Perfect New Year’s Resolution: Developing your Estate Plan

Andrew P. HerreraBlog Post

What is your New Year’s resolution? Is it to lose weight? Is it to exercise more? Is it to save more money? What about preparing an estate plan? That’s something that’s been on a lot of people’s lists for quite some time but they never seem to get there. Oftentimes that’s because they’re unsure of what is actually involved. This blog addresses the fundamentals involved in creating an estate plan.

Key questions to consider when creating an estate plan are:

  • What does my estate consist of?
  • Who should I consult regarding my estate plan?
  • What estate planning documents do I need?

What does my estate consist of?

Your estate includes all property owned by you less your debts and liabilities. In order to properly plan your estate and assist your attorney in preparing the necessary estate planning documents, you should prepare an inventory of your assets, which would include the following:

  1. Description and location of the assets;
  2. Ownership interest;
  3. Value of the asset (cost/market value);
  4. Debts/liens; and
  5. Beneficiary designation, if applicable.

Preparing and periodically updating your inventory of assets will help avoid issues and minimize time and money spent in locating and marshalling your assets after your death.

Who should I consult regarding my estate plan?

 There are four key individuals that are involved in creating an estate plan:

  1. Your attorney is the individual responsible for the overall creation of your estate plan.
  2. Your accountant may be contacted to provide financial information needed to properly identify your assets and liabilities.
  3. The beneficiaries are the individuals who will inherit your assets upon your death.
  4. The fiduciary/executor is the individual in charge of your estate who will be working with your attorney in marshalling your assets, paying your debts, and distributing your assets to the beneficiaries.

What estate planning documents do I need?

The essential estate plan includes a Last Will and Testament, Power of Attorney, and a Health Care Proxy. In addition, there are a number of other advance directives that should be included in order to make your wishes clear.

  • Living Will
  • HIPAA Disclosure
  • Nomination of Guardian
  • Appointment of Agent for Disposition of Remains

Please feel free to contact the attorneys of the Trusts & Estates Group at Goetz Fitzpatrick LLP at 212.695.8100 ext. 289 to discuss any questions you may have regarding creating or updating your estate plan.


New Power of Attorney Legislation

Andrew P. HerreraBlog Post

On December 15, 2020, Governor Andrew Cuomo signed new legislation changing the NYS Power of Attorney. The new law becomes effective on June 13, 2021. The changes are intended to simplify and make the Power of Attorney a more user-friendly document. Two of the most significant changes are:

1. The elimination of the Statutory Gifts Rider, a separate form that was required to be included with a power of attorney that allowed the agent to give gifts. It can now be added in the modifications section of the POA. Absent this modification, an agent may make gifts up to $5,000 annually.

2. The addition of the procedure for the refusal to honor a Power of Attorney. Third parties have 10 days to honor or reject the power of attorney. Notice of any rejection must be sent in writing to the principal and the agent unless there is suspicion of abuse and the case has been referred to Adult Protective Services. The court may award damages, including reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, if the court finds that the third party acted unreasonably in refusing to honor the agent’s authority.

Other changes to the Power of Attorney include:

3. “Substantially conforms to the wording” replaces “exact wording.” Under previous law, banking institutions, for example, may refuse to accept a POA because of something minor like a misspelling, which rendered it a non-statutory form. Under the new law, failing to include clauses that are not relevant to a given power of attorney shall not invalidate the power of attorney.

4. Any section indicated as “Optional” may be omitted and replaced by “Intentionally Omitted.” This negates the need to include provisions that are rarely used and do not apply.

5. People unable to sign will be able to direct someone else to sign on their behalf. The power of attorney must be signed by two witnesses (one of whom can be the notary).

6. Changes to the Construction Sections.

Banking
Changes cannot be made to Joint Accounts unless the authority to make changes is expressly stated in the Modifications Section.

If a Power of Attorney requires that two or more agents act together as co-agents, one or more agents may delegate to the co-agent the authority to conduct banking transactions if the principal initialed subject (o) in the grant of authority provisions of paragraph (f) of the statutory short form.

Financial Matters Related to Health Care
This authority shall not include the authorization for the agent to make health care decisions for the principal.

Retirement Benefit Transactions
Changes cannot be made to beneficiary designations unless the authority to make changes is expressly stated in the Modifications Section.

Please feel free to contact the attorneys of the Trusts & Estates Group at Goetz Fitzpatrick LLP at 212.695.8100 ext. 289 to discuss any questions you may have regarding the new Power of Attorney and whether your estate plan needs to be updated accordingly.

 


Podcast: Charitable Fundraising in the Time of COVID

Howard RubinBlog Post

Listen to the podcast >>

As Trustee of the Herbert M. Citrin Charitable Foundation, Goetz Fitzpatrick partner Howard Rubin is a philanthropist who is actively involved in charitable fundraising, an area that has been hit just as hard as his legal practice area focuses in the hospitality and restaurant industries. Recently, Howard was interviewed by Fairways & Fundraising, a podcast put on by Golf Event Planning. As Howard prepares for his first golf charity fundraiser since the onset of COVID, he and host Larry Battaglia, owner of Golf Event Planning, discuss the feeling and vibe of the City after COVID, how Howard became Trustee of the Herbert M. Citrin Charitable Foundation, how fundraising is navigating event logistics in order to put them on responsibly, and what they see for the future.

Many of Goetz Fitzpatrick’s partners are active philanthropists and, not surprisingly, many of their affiliations stemmed from relationships they have built with their clients. “I always prefer to have clients rather than cases,” Howard shares in the podcast. “One of those people was Herb Citrin.” As a long-time client of Howard’s, Herb Citrin decided that, upon his death, he wanted to establish a foundation and made Howard one of the co-trustees. He and the other trustees focus on making grants that will grow and appreciate so that they can do more and more good for people, not just now but in the future.

Listen to the podcast to learn more. 


Sumner Redstone’s $3 Billion Estate

Alison Arden BesunderBlog Post

Four years ago, at the age of 93, self-made billionaire Sumner Redstone made notable changes to his empire, removing Viacom CEO Philippe Dauman and board member George Abrams from his trust, appointing his lawyer and a family friend to replace them, and naming one of his granddaughters to the board of National Amusements, his holding company. On August 11, 2020, at the age of 97, the attorney-turned-media mogul died.

Redstone, regarded as a savvy businessman and fierce competitor well into his 90s, revised his will multiple times, most recently in 2015 when he removed former girlfriend Manuela Herzer, 42 years his junior, as a beneficiary of $50 million and his Beverly Hills mansion. The lawsuit brought by Herzer challenging Redstone’s mental capacity and her removal from the will was finally resolved last year when a judge ruled that he was of sound mind to amend his trust in 2015, reinstating his 2003 trust which reportedly names his five grandchildren as beneficiaries.

Despite many attempts by former executives and competitors to wrest control of Viacom from Redstone, he and his daughter Shari remained controlling shareholders. Redstone’s personal net worth is estimated at $3 billion, according to Forbes, with his daughter being one of seven trustees of Redstone’s 80% stake in holding company National Amusements.

While Sumner Redstone’s last will and testament could be contested, his active involvement in the planning of his estate and the recent ruling upholding his 2003 trust make it unlikely that a contesting party would prevail.


Now is an Ideal Time to Add a GRAT to Your Estate Plan

Christopher CanfieldBlog Post

Do you want to reduce estate and gift taxes for your beneficiaries? With interest rates close to zero and potentially depressed asset valuations, conditions are ideal for adding a Grantor Retained Annuity Trust (GRAT) to your estate planning portfolio. Simply put, a GRAT is a trust that holds business, investment, or real estate assets for a set term, with a two-year minimum. For each year of the trust term an annuity must be paid back to the Grantor and, upon termination of the trust, the remaining assets pass to the beneficiaries estate and gift tax free. GRATS are an excellent way to transfer assets at a reduced or even eliminated transfer tax cost.

How GRATS Generate Tax Savings

The year the GRAT is funded, the Grantor files a gift tax return to report the taxable gift portion of the transaction. This is calculated based on actuarial tables which vary depending on the terms of the trust. Goetz Fitzpatrick can help determine those calculations. Similar to a Qualified Personal Residence Trust (QPRT), the longer the term of the trust, the lower the taxable gift. However, if the Grantor dies during the trust term, the trust folds back into their estate, negating the tax benefits for beneficiaries. The annuity that must be paid to the Grantor can be set at any amount and the greater the annuity, the lower the taxable gift. It is common to do “rolling GRATS,” which are short-term GRATS that the Grantor renews over and over again to maximize the tax benefits while limiting the risk of reversion to the estate.

Pass On Appreciation Tax Free 

A GRAT can also be “zeroed out,” meaning that the taxable gift is zero. A zeroed-out GRAT would require that 100% of the value of assets put in the trust plus the Applicable Federal Rate (AFR) of interest be paid out to the Grantor during the trust term. If the trust assets outperform the AFR (currently less than 1%) over the trust term, all of that excess appreciation and income pass to the beneficiary estate and gift tax free. The taxable income earned during the trust term is reported by, and the income tax is paid by, the Grantor, which actually provides further advantages to the beneficiary.

The Cost of a GRAT

Legal and tax prep fees as well as recurring appraisal fees are generally required. If rolling GRATS are used, new trusts are created every two years or so and qualified appraisals of assets are required each time. In addition, it is best to utilize LLCs or limited partnerships to simplify the continual transfers of ownership interests among the Grantor, the Trust, and the Beneficiaries, so that could be an extra cost. Further benefits can be achieved by utilizing valuation discounts for gifts of minority interests and these require specialized appraisals.

Because of the complexity and costs involved, it is best to consult with your estate planning attorney to find out if a GRAT is appropriate for you. However, if the current elevated federal estate tax exemption truly sunsets on December 31, 2025 as planned, a broader range of estates would benefit from using GRATS as well as other sophisticated estate tax planning tools.


Q&A—What Are Digital Assets and How Do I Plan for Them in My Estate?

Alison Arden BesunderBlog Post

You may often hear the term “digital assets” bandied about, but what does it mean? Here are answers to some frequently asked questions about digital assets and how to manage them.

What is a Digital Legacy?

A legacy is anything you leave behind when you die. Technically, the definition is “something transmitted by or received from an ancestor or predecessor.” People generally want to leave a legacy because they want to feel that their life mattered. This typically means making a contribution to future generations, whether that be money, valuables, or memories. Not all that long ago this was pretty straightforward, but in the age of technology, your digital assets can be buried in an intricate rabbit hole of digital footprints and, without a roadmap, they may never be found.

What Digital Assets Are We Talking About?

Digital assets can be divided into several categories. These include:

Personal Assets Photographs, videos, music, and other creative montages.

Social Media Assets Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, YouTube, Pinterest, and other social media accounts, both personal and business. These can have a hard monetary value based on followers.

Financial Assets Venmo or Paypal as well as bitcoin and cryptocurrency fall into the category of digital financial assets. Access to online bank accounts does not constitute a digital asset nor is the underlying asset held in an online bank account a digital asset.

Business Assets Deeds, possessions, intellectual property, the company itself and/or its stock.

Domain Names / Blogs Personal web domains. These can also command a hard monetary value.

Loyalty Programs Earned miles or points that may be transferrable upon death.

What Do I Need to Do to Include My Digital Assets in My Estate Planning?

Get organized

  1. Consider whether you want someone to access the content of your email during your lifetime, in the event of incapacity, or after your death.

  2. Consider whether you want your social media accounts preserved.

  3. Consider what you want to happen to your photographs, the data on your apps, and assets such as eBooks, music, and videos.

  4. If social media accounts have monetary value, consider transferring them to a business or a trust, appointing a digital executor, or giving the general executor specific authority to deal with the social media accounts.

  5. If the social media provider has an online option for how your assets are managed upon death, make sure you complete their form.

  6. Review your digital legacy plan every year.

How Can an Attorney Support Me in My Digital Asset Planning?

Attorneys cannot access your digital assets without violating communication laws, nor can they organize your digital assets for you. Clients generally do not want to pay attorneys for something they can take care of themselves. Generally, you want to organize your estate as much as possible, including documenting and planning for how your digital assets will be handled. Once you have compiled this information, an attorney can help you integrate it into your overall estate plan.

What’s the Best Advice You Can Give to People About Their Digital Legacy?

Make a list of all accounts and passwords and keep it in a secure place. Update it regularly.

Write a letter to your family or executor that includes access credentials and instructions. Tell the person what you want to happen with each account. If you don’t want anyone accessing certain digital assets, say so. Keep the letter in a safe place with your other important documents. Important: Do not include this information in your will, as your will is a public document.

Back up your important digital data to a separate, secure hard drive or other secure device. Replicate your backup—hard drives and memory sticks can fail. Set a tickler in your calendar to run a backup quarterly.

Explicitly authorize the companies that hold electronic data to release that data to your fiduciaries in the event of incapacity or death—or not. Settings in Google and Facebook allow those companies to disclose certain digital assets and/or content of electronic communications to the fiduciaries upon your request.

What’s One of the Biggest Things You’d Like to See Improved Upon in Digital Asset Planning? 

  1. There is a bill pending in the New York State Assembly that would allow executors to access social media accounts. The bill remains in committee and has not been presented for vote. This would take a lot of the legwork out of the process for clients.

  2. New York adopted a version of the Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act (RUFADAA), which gives guidance on how to leave digital assets behind and what empowers a fiduciary, such as an executor or trustee, to access a person’s digital estate. New York could take this further to be uniform with other states’ laws. Otherwise, this can leave New York State fiduciaries at the direction of the terms of use. More than 20 states have adopted the uniform act in its entirety. 

More Resources:

Watch my video, “How Do I Account for Digital Assets in My Will?”

Read my New York Family Magazine article, “There are Ways to Pass On Your Passwords”

Read my New York Family Magazine article, “What Cryonics and Bitcoin Mean for Your Future”

Read my blog article, “5 Important Steps in Planning for Your Digital Afterlife”


Remote Notarization Permitted Under Executive Order

Alison Arden BesunderBlog Post

On March 19, 2020, Governor Andrew Cuomo issued a temporary modification of law that authorizes any notarial act that is required under New York State law to be performed utilizing audio-video technology, subject to the following conditions:

  • The person seeking the Notary’s services, if not personally known to the Notary, must present valid photo ID to the Notary during the video conference, not merely transmit it prior to or after;

  • The video conference must allow for direct interaction between the person and the Notary (e.g. no pre-recorded videos of the person signing);

  • The person must affirmatively represent that he or she is physically situated in the State of New York;

  • The person must transmit by fax or electronic means a legible copy of the signed document directly to the Notary on the same date it was signed;

  • The Notary may notarize the transmitted copy of the document and transmit the same back to the person; and

  • The Notary may repeat the notarization of the original signed document as of the date of execution provided the Notary receives such original signed document together with the electronically notarized copy within thirty days after the date of execution.

Read the Governor’s full executive order here.